
Filming a video message for the happy couple
It isn’t often that we’re able to see outside of ourselves and feel the spinning of the earth slow as moment in time becomes pivotal to our lives. Becomes a part of not only our personal history, but our people’s history. September 11th, 2001 was one of those days, but June 18th, 2011 was even more so.
The air was warm and charged with expectation and the scent of the redwoods. I sat at a table in the grass, surrounded by friends I had bumbled through teenagerhood with, along with two special people. One was my sister, who is my other half. The other was a young man who is family in all but blood. We met at pre-school and became friends before we were three.
The chatter of the voices around us quieted as music began to play. Down the handmade stage came the wedding party. Then the groom, MrD., whose face was still that of the boy I had teased years ago, now had the confidence of a man following his dreams. Then the bride, MissL., a young woman who has inspired me by her kindness and compassion since the day we met in junior high. They were high school sweethearts who had taken their time to get to this place of union, which made it all the more festive for us guests. We finally had a chance to show them not only how happy we were for them, but how proud.
When the videographer came around after the ceremony, recording well-wishes for the happy couple, I had something to say. I didn’t know until afterwards that the entire time I was speaking into the lens, my friend from pre-school, MrT., was making funny faces in the background. Trust me, he’s good at those. Too good.
While I laughed at the revelation, I felt time slow and realized how lucky I am. How lucky we all are. Through the lens of that camera, imprinted on magnetic tape, is a record not only of survival, but of resilience and hope. It had been ten years, and we were all well.
The morning of September 11th, 2001, I rushed into my 7am video productions class. I was irritated because my mother and siblings were all leaving after school to camp at the county fair with their livestock for the week and I would miss them. I stepped into the classroom to find the few students who were there on time watching the big screen TV. With the teacher. Anytime a teacher had us watch the news, it was a big deal. I was sickly let down when I saw that it was just a burning building in Manhattan on the screen. Why did New York get so much attention whenever any little thing happened there?
I asked what was going on and someone said that a plane had hit. I assumed it was an accident until I watched the second plane explode against the tower. I felt the working of my brain shift and try to rewire. For some reason, I couldn’t get over the fact that a plane crashing into a building actually looked exactly as you thought it would. Now that I’m older, I think what confused me the most wasn’t the truth of the image, but rather, the fact that there was no doubt behind the intention. Whoever was flying that plane was aiming for the second tower.
I sank into my seat amidst gasps from my fellow students as we watched the horror unfold on the big screen. I felt a pang of compassion for each new student who entered and wondered what was going on. I’ll never forget how silent the room was. How my blood-brother from pre-school was at my side, whispering “Oh my God,” for me when I could no longer speak.
Firemen were stopped by a reporter as they rushed towards the towers and one paused to speak. I don’t remember what he said, but I remember it was harried and that I felt a sense of comfort once they arrived. They would help everyone. They would put out the fires and fix things. Then the tower fell and that relief turned into numb anguish as we realized that every man who we just saw had died. Watching the steel crumble and the billowing clouds of debris, I wanted to cry. I needed to cry. I was able to force tears into my eyes, but they wouldn’t fall. I don’t know if they ever did.
I kept hoping that another American hadn’t done this, like one had in the Oklahoma City bombing when I was in sixth grade. I kept thinking that we were seniors in high school and that it wasn’t fair that this was the world we were inheriting. It wasn’t fair that the choices that had led up to that horrible attack weren’t ours. As a Californian who had never been across the Mississippi, until that day, I hadn’t even known what the two towers were. What Afghanistan was. But I knew who Osama bin Laden was. I stayed up late once and watched an episode of 60 Minutes (I think) that interviewed him. He promised to kill us all. I couldn’t understand why they didn’t do him then and there when they knew from the U.S. Embassy Bombings he was capable of following through with his threats.
I don’t remember the order, but we saw scenes of the smoldering wall of the Pentagon, heard of a rogue plane still in the air, headed for the White House, and a bomb in a car outside of Congress. That last report turned out to be false, but at the time, and at seventeen-years-old, it felt like the world was collapsing around us.
I left the room to call my mom on the payphone since we didn’t all have cells then. I don’t know why I called her. I was worried that between taking my younger siblings to school and getting ready for the fair, she wouldn’t have heard about what was going on. I think I thought I could protect her if she didn’t leave the house. But really, I wanted comfort. I left a message.
When I returned to the classroom, our teacher had the wisdom to mute the TV and to tell us to go to work on our video projects. No one could focus. Least of all my group. We were editing a video about the end of mankind, using footage from Hiroshima and Nagasaki. We had thought we were being clever, prescient even, by making such an eerie short. On that day, we realized that we were right, and it was awful.
Our teacher came over to use and knew exactly what to say when he saw us staring at our timeline of black and white footage. “I hope you know you didn’t cause this.” We all nervously giggled. Nervous because we’d all been thinking the same thing. Our cynicism had been rewarded. We were harbingers too late.
The next class of the day was Economics and the second tower fell. The screen went dark and the anchormen and women gasped and fell silent and I knew no adults were in control. No one was. Then whistles sounded from all over on the screen. I thought they were alarms until a girl in class said that they were whistles on the jackets of firemen and they only went off when the fireman was no longer moving. The bottom dropped out of my stomach. Then a woman stepped into the classroom, called my name, and asked me to go with her.
I rose and stiffly followed while every eye in the classroom lingered on me. My mind was racing. I had no family in New York, at least not that I was in touch with. My dad was at work. Everyone should be safe, shouldn’t they? Was there another attack in California? Outside of the classroom, the woman tried to chat with me about something inconsequential, and I practiced my fake smile. Then I saw my mom and baby brother and sister waiting for me. No one we knew had died. They just wanted to see me before they left.
“They’re saying it’s worse than Pearl Harbor,” my little brother said. He was twelve and my sister was nine and they had already seen so much. It wasn’t fair.
I didn’t want to tell him that it might have been ten times worse than Pearl Harbor, for at the time, casualty estimates were around an exaggerated 60,000. Instead, I muttered “I know.”
They were still going to the fair, which surprised me. But what could be more American, what could be more defiant than continuing with rural life and commerce in the face of such hatred of our lifestyle. They wanted me to go with them but I was always serious about school and didn’t want to miss any. I hugged them all goodbye then returned to class.
The drive home felt long. Within a few hours, it looked like everyone in town had pulled out their Independence Day decorations. Patriotic bunting decorated fences. Red, white and blue ribbons were on antennae. American flags flew from cars. It was so organic and genuine that I have never seen an equal outpouring of support and brotherhood. I probably never will.
I didn’t want to be home alone that afternoon, and neither did one of my childhood friends, MissE., so she came over and after failing to complete even part of our Spanish homework because of our nerves, we made cookie dough and ate it. We watched Mayor Rudolph Guiliani give a speech. It was relieving to see at least one adult who was poised and composed, even after his city had been attacked. That night, my heart swelled as our oft-bumbling leader showed no sign of weakness and spoke to our nation of resolve, unity, strength, and retaliation.
I shouldn’t have been alone that week. My dad was around but he was at work most of the day. The silent skies were as peaceful as they were eerie. I became glued to the TV. Every morning for two weeks, I woke up at 5am and painted an American flag on my bicep. In my junior year, I had seriously considered joining the Navy. I took the ASVAB and interpreted my results with recruiters. I even considered shaving my head and talked about it so often that one of my friends shaved her head, instead. I had ultimately decided to go to college, but after the attacks, the old desire to matter returned with passion.
Our teachers kept asking us how we felt, trying to get us to talk. Our Economics teacher made all sorts of jokes. He went out of his way to make us laugh, like looking up conspiracy theories that claimed the Amish were responsible for the attacks. During one of these amusing moments, everyone fell silent at the sound of a plane. Several of us looked out the window. A girl in class laughed at our own flightiness. “It’s just a crop duster.” Poking fun at ourselves felt empowering. Yet still, I remember gazing at the newspapers from September 9th and 10th with longing, wishing to return to that simple world before such hate attacked our innocence.
In one class, our discussions often turned into arguments. People were eager to lay blame for what happened. Eager to express their frustration as anger, especially the boys. During one of these heated discussions, my friend from pre-school, MrT., revealed that he had enlisted and joined the 82nd Airborne. He was going to be a paratrooper.
I came home shaken. When he had tried homeschool in sixth grade, so had I. It was pretty awful, and shortly after he had left, so had I. Now he had joined the military. I wanted to follow again.
One day, after the President’s speech asking every American to serve their country in some way, after being turned away when I tried to donate blood because they had too many volunteers, after only two people (one of which was MissL.) showed up at my 18th birthday party because it was the same day we attacked Afghanistan and their parents didn’t let them leave the house for fear of retaliation, I lay on my bed and made a decision. I called my mom into my room and asked her to take me to the recruiter station in Capitola.
She just stared. “Why?”
“Because I want to join the Navy.”
I remember being mad that she wouldn’t take me. That she didn’t approve. That she told me I shouldn’t make such decisions while I was emotional. But a part of me was relieved that she was stopping me. And now I am happy that she convinced me that I could serve my country in other ways. The recruiters never told me what a different place the military is for women.
In the end, irritated by how my fellow students were talking about trips to the snow instead of the recent war we were waging if Afghanistan, I made a video. It didn’t take much work and was pretty sappy, but it got the job done. It was scenes of the US, then Christmas, then two soldiers in the desert, played by my brothers. One was dead. The end read “Not everyone will be home for Christmas.” It was shown at the winter assembly in front of the whole school. Several ran out of the gym crying. Other students half-jokingly accused me of “ruining their winter break” over the rest of the day. That was the point.
Later that year, MissL left our Government class in tears. Getting out of my seat, our teacher nodded her silent approval that it was fine for me to miss class to comfort her. We sat on the steps outside as I listened to what was troubling her. Some time ago, she and our friend MrD started dating. When her mother found out how serious they were, she didn’t approve, citing differences in their cultures because one of his parents was from the Middle East. There are differences between everyone, but we all grew up together in the same sheltered valley. To us, they would’ve had more differences if he’d been from Scott’s Valley, our rich rival high school. But still, her mother was trying to protect her daughter from a world she thought wouldn’t allow her and MrD to be together. Something she never would’ve worried about if not for September 11th.
We graduated, parted ways for college. MrT wrote to send me updates from boot camp. At my university, I attended a talk on the possible invasion of Iraq. The panel of professors and attendees quickly disintegrated into a shouting match. The older generation had lost control again, which wasn’t fair when my peers were maintaining their control and making the choice to serve. I had class so I left the shouts that we would never get out of Iraq once we were in, that thousands of our soldiers would be killed. Or at least I tried to. I had to take a math test and was so worried about MrT being sent to war that I came as close to failing a test in college as I have ever done.
In the end, as we all know, we did invade. MrT served two tours in Iraq. Once, while on the phone with him, I heard distant pop. He laughed and said the locals liked to take shots at the compound every once in a while. His parents were on the front page of the local paper, holding his picture, saying they faced the reality that he might not come home every day. This was made all the more real when another young man who I had the pleasure of meeting a few times was killed. To this day, MrT wears a bracelet in honor of his memory and sacrifice.
Since we were small, MrT has always stolen my Runts whenever I have had the favorite candy sitting out. While he was in Iraq, we often sent him packages full of Runts, which were one of the few treats that could survive in the desert. Now MrT is home, and though I gave him five boxes for his birthday, still steals my Runts when he visits, which is as it should be.
I know everyone was affected by September 11th, 2001. Some more than others, especially those in NYC. But on that happy June day in 2011, surrounded by friends, I realized just how much it has shaped the lives of our generation. We literally came of age amidst the turmoil. We were young enough to have had innocence taken that day, yet old enough to have the adults in our lives not know what to do or say to help us make sense of it all.
Ten years later, we still don’t know how to make sense of it all, but we live in an altered world. That day in June, Osama bin Laden had been dead for a little over a month. Our soldiers were finally pulling out of Iraq. Approaching our ten year high school reunion, attending a wedding, we all felt very grown up.
In the lens of that video camera is the girl telling her story of how the love between her friends was stronger than prejudice. Behind her is the soldier, still goofy as ever, alive and well after rising to the call and serving his nation. We were brought together to celebrate not only our friends, but being alive.
September 11th, 2001 may have been a day of sorrow and death that marked us forever. But June 18th, 2011, was a day of joy and new life that will always give me faith in hope. We truly are the lucky ones.